Some Tells We Shouldn't Ignore- How to Spot A Struggling Responder

First responders don’t ask for help well.

We are the help.

We’re trained to move toward chaos, absorb stress, and keep functioning. We see things most people never will, then we’re expected to shut it off and go home like nothing ever happened. The problem is, the brain doesn’t work that way. The body doesn’t forget.

Most responders will never say, “I’m not okay.”

But there are tells. And if you’ve been in the responder services long enough, you already know that.

Tell #1: A Nervous System That Won’t Stand Down

Watch the legs. Watch the hands.

Constant leg bouncing. Fidgeting. Pacing. Always moving. Like a crack head.

People brush it off as habit. It's usually not. — it’s a nervous system stuck in high alert.

Adrenaline without relief. A brain that hasn’t felt safe enough to power down. You can ignore it for a while, but you can’t outrun it forever.

Tell #2: Personality Shifts You Can’t Explain Away

This one is obvious — and still gets dismissed.

Quiet, reserved people suddenly acting reckless or impulsive?

That’s a change.

Outgoing, upbeat people suddenly isolating, withdrawing, snapping at everyone?

That’s a change too.

We work around each other more than we see our families. You know your people. When their baseline shifts, don’t minimize it. Those changes are tells.

Tell #3: Cold Hands Don’t Lie

This one doesn’t care about opinions.

Chronic stress and anxiety cause vasoconstriction. Blood pulls inward. Skin temperature drops. Hands get cold.

I’ll tape a thermometer to a responder’s pinky. There’s a chart that correlates surface temperature to stress levels — and it lines up consistently.

Here’s the bottom line:

If your hands are cold all the time, your nervous system is running the show.

I tell responders this: let your hands be your measure.

Cold hands mean your body is locked in survival mode.

You either decompress intentionally — or your body will force it.

Why This Matters

Responders don’t volunteer vulnerability. The stigma is real. The fear is real. Waiting for someone to ask for help usually means waiting too long.

That’s why officers need to know the tells.

Not to micromanage people — but to protect them.

A quiet check-in. A direct conversation. Early intervention before things unravel.

Because once someone crashes, the damage rarely stops with them.

My Thoughts

It never fails. I can be giving a presentation at an agency, and there is at least 1 maybe 2 responders sitting in the back with the chicken leg cranking away at 180 beats per minute. I will see tells on people at church, the store, virtually everywhere.

God didn’t design the human nervous system for permanent fight-or-flight. And He didn’t design us to carry trauma alone — especially in a profession built on shared burden.

If you see the tells in someone else, speak up.

If you see them in yourself, don’t ignore them.

Pay attention. Take care of your people. Take care of your brain.

Lives depend on it — including yours.

Stay safe out there.

-Tom

Take care, brothers, lest there be in any of you an evil, unbelieving heart, leading you to fall away from the living God. But exhort one another every day,

Hebrews 3:12–13

We are a trauma-informed 501(c)(3) on a mission to bring hope, healing, and restoration to first responders and their families- Through chaplaincy, crisis response, formal training, and peer support initiatives, we strive to educate and offer support. Please consider donating today at http://www.riseupfight.org/donate